Taxation as the Art of Preserving Cultural Heritage
When we look at an elegant ancient building, a magnificent temple or a masterpiece painting in a museum, our minds often drift to the golden age of history, aesthetic romanticism and the spiritual pride of a nation.
Preserving such cultural heritage is no easy task. When these relics begin to succumb to the ravages of time, the question immediately arises: where does the money for restoration come from?
Amidst mounting budget deficits, surging social security expenditure and environmental crises, the cultural sector is frequently the first line item to be cut by vote-seeking politicians at election time.
Through a volume edited by four international tax law experts: Lorenzo del Federico, Sigrid Hemels, José-Andrés Rozas and Silvia Giorgi, Taxation and Cultural Heritage. dissects what amounts to a genuine paradox.
Del Federico et al. reject the notion that discussions of taxation on cultural heritage are merely a matter of figures. Published in 2021, the book comprises 26 chapters examining European Union tax law, OECD and UNESCO guidelines and comparative studies across more than 20 countries.
The book invites readers to understand two economic foundations underpinning the case for the state to preserve culture through fiscal instruments: Pigouvian positive externalities and Baumol's cost disease.
Enjoying the Benefits Without Paying
Imagine the owner of an ancient building in the heart of an old town who dips into their personal funds to restore the antique façade. The building beautifies the city's landscape and attracts thousands of curious tourists.
Coffee shops, restaurants, hotels and souvenir stores nearby are flooded with customers and reap substantial profits (positive externalities). Yet not one of them pays a penny to the owner of that historic building.
This is what is known as market failure: the building's owner bears the full cost of expensive conservation while others do not.
Without tax incentives from the government, owners are likely to take the path of least resistance; allowing the building to fall into natural decay or demolishing it to make way for a more profitable modern shophouse.
Baumol's Violin Disease
In modern manufacturing, technological advances and automation can multiply productivity, particularly through time efficiency.
Citing Baumol and Bowen (1966), a violin played today to perform a Mozart symphony written two hundred years ago requires precisely the same amount of time to bow as it did then.
Similarly, restoring a classical painting, reassembling the weathered stones of a temple or caring for ancient manuscripts demands extraordinary human skill and craftsmanship.
As a result, conservation labour costs continue to rise sharply without keeping pace with wage standards, while the speed of the work remains constant.
Once again, without tax incentives or an injection of public funds, maintaining cultural heritage becomes a heavy financial burden for whoever owns it.
To explore the art of preserving cultural heritage in greater depth, Del Federico et al. invite readers to trace the experiences of various countries in using taxation as a tool.
From Ransom to Heritage Lottery
One of the landmark instruments examined by Hemels is the mechanism for settling a tax liability using works of art or cultural heritage objects.
When a wealthy art collector passes away, their heirs/heiress are often confronted with an inheritance tax. If the heirs/heiress cannot pay, they are forced to auction the works, with the risk that historically significant pieces disappear from public view.
To prevent this, several countries have opened the door to tax settlement schemes. In the United Kingdom, the acceptance in lieu scheme is well established. The government provides an incentive of 25% above the tax otherwise payable. This scheme successfully preserved the original text of Charles Darwin's On the Origin of Species.
In France, the dation en paiement scheme was the cornerstone behind the creation of the world-renowned Musée Picasso in Paris. The heirs/heiress of Pablo Picasso settled the inheritance tax by donating hundreds of the maestro's paintings and sculptures to the state.
France has also launched the loto du patrimoine, i.e., a dedicated lottery to fund the restoration of endangered historic monuments.
The Netherlands takes a particularly generous approach. The state values works of art at 120% of their appraised value when used to settle inheritance tax. However, Hemels reveals a fatal flaw in this scheme: there is no clause requiring that the works be made available for public display.
In 2004, heirs/heiress of the Dutch royal family enjoyed inheritance tax relief of up to EUR8.8 million, yet the most expensive painting, valued at EUR2.5 million, from that estate was hung in the private study of King Willem-Alexander at the Dam Square Palace.
This scandal served as a stark warning to policymakers that every penny of tax incentive granted must be repaid through public access rights and transparency.
In Italy, meanwhile, the government involves the public through private-sector donations. A tax credit of 65% is granted to individuals or corporations that donate funds towards the maintenance of cultural heritage.
It is precisely these incentives that have given rise to a wave of public-private partnerships. It comes as no surprise that Tod's and Fendi, guardians of the elegant Made in Italy image renowned worldwide, have embraced this model.
Tod's funded the restoration of the Colosseum to the tune of EUR25 million, while Fendi contributed nearly EUR3 million to restore the Trevi Fountain.
The contributors to this book are not naive in their assessment of tax incentives. They examine how wherever tax facilities exist, there is scope for abuse, elitism, and even tax avoidance.
When Culture Becomes an Alibi
In one chapter, Francesco Montanari uncovers the phenomenon of free ports in Geneva, Luxembourg and Singapore. Originally designed as transit zones for industrial trade, these free zones have become vast vaults storing thousands of masterworks.
Situated in areas with high-security facilities and exempt from VAT and import duty, an expensive painting can change ownership without physically moving an inch.
This implies that works that ought to be enjoyed by the wider public instead become speculative assets far beyond the reach of tax authorities and vulnerable to money-laundering crimes.
In addition, Loris Tosi and Ernesto-Marco Bagarotto paint a sobering picture of art cities such as Venice, threatened by mass tourism. The millions of tourists who arrive each year damage the physical fabric of ancient streets and historic canals, while the costs of cleaning and maintaining the city continue to balloon.
Tosi and Bagarotto examine taxation as an instrument in this context. Tax in art cities is no longer solely a tool for collecting local revenue; it becomes a disincentive to manage the urban environment.
In another chapter, Ricardo Garcia Antón criticises countries that embrace paternalism. Antón advocates a paradigm shift; away from the state as the sole arbiter of cultural heritage value, towards a community-centred approach.
Through cultural heritage cooperatives, local communities at village or town level take an active role in managing, maintaining and revitalising the civilisational legacy in their surroundings, supported by democratic tax facilities.
Reflections for the Archipelago
Indonesia possesses an abundance of cultural heritage, from the temples of Borobudur and Prambanan, megalithic site landscapes and historic royal palaces, to thousands of traditional ancestral dwellings and rows of old colonial-era buildings.
Regrettably, the approach adopted by most stakeholders still relies predominantly on conventional subsidies from the central and regional government budgets, or else leaves matters entirely to private-sector commercialisation.
For example, owners of ancient ancestral buildings in various old town centres must pay a punishing land and building tax owing to rising government-assessed property values, whilst being prohibited from altering or selling the properties because of regulatory constraints.
Through this book, several ideas emerge that could inform a cultural fiscal roadmap for Indonesia. For instance, land and building tax discounts for owners of heritage buildings, a supertax deduction scheme for corporate restoration donations, or a payment-in-kind scheme along the lines of those in the United Kingdom and France.
Ultimately, this book demonstrates that tax law and cultural studies can walk hand in hand. In the hands of policymakers, taxation can become a flexible and powerful brush for preserving the legacy of civilisation.
Interested in reading this book? Please visit DDTC Library.
To date, DDTC Library holds a total of 5,096 literature items supporting the study of taxation as a multidisciplinary field and has been recognised with a MURI Record as the Tax Library with the Largest Collection in Indonesia.
Before visiting DDTC Library, members of the public are welcome to confirm their visit in advance via the hotline: +62-21-2938-2700 or email: [email protected]. You may also follow the DDTC Library Instagram account for the latest information on tax literature. (dik)

